Repairing vs Replacing a Garage Door

3August 2023

Your garage door is an essential component to your home. It provides security, insulation, convenience and curb appeal. Garage doors, however, do require repairs or replacement over time. You might be wondering if it is worth it to repair your garage door or if it’s best to replace it altogether.

Potential Expenses for Common Garage Door Repairs

Garage doors have many components that overtime may need repair. The most common repairs include the replacement of panels, springs, and garage door openers.

  • Panel Replacement – To replace a damaged panel, the average cost is between $150 – $500, depending on the material, design and insulation properties of the garage door.
  • Spring Repair – Garage door springs are responsible for counterbalancing the weight of the door and are crucial for assisting in its smooth operation. Over time springs may break or lose tension. The average cost of spring repair ranges from $200 to $500. Please note that attempting to repair or replace springs without professional assistance can be dangerous and should be avoided.
  • Garage Door Opener Repair – Common issues with garage door openers include a worn-out motor, damaged components or faulty wiring. Depending on the issue, repair can range, on average, from $100 to $800.

The Cost of Purchasing and Installing a New Garage Door

Purchasing a new garage door can cost more initially, but doing so can provide longer term benefits and cost savings.

  • Garage Door Costs – The cost of a new garage door depends on factors such as material, design, insulation and size. On average, you can expect to spend between $1,000 and $3,500 for a standard-sized, non-custom door. Advanced insulation features and unique design can increase the cost of the garage door significantly.
  • Delivery and Installation – It is advisable to hire a  garage door service professional to install your garage door. The delivery and installation cost can range from $500 to $1500 depending on the complexity of the installation.

Additional Factors When Considering Repairing or Replacing a Garage Door

When deciding on whether to repair or replace a garage door, it is important to consider the age of the door, its overall condition and energy efficiency as well as safety considerations.

  • Age and Condition – The average lifespan of a garage door is 15-30 years. If your garage door has seen frequent repairs, it might be time to replace it. The cost of repairs can quickly add up, making replacing it a more practical and cost effective choice.
  • Energy Efficiency – Older garage doors are typically less energy efficient. Purchasing a new, energy efficient door can be a cost savings over time, while improving the comfort of the garage.
  • Safety – Since garage doors are heavy, they are potentially dangerous if they are not in proper working order. If you are experiencing safety issues such as imbalanced springs or malfunctioning openers, replacing the system may be the safest solution.

When considering repairing or replacing a garage door, many factors can impact the decision. Give us a call at 225-281-6346 to discuss your options with our professional and experienced team.